What’s Worse: A Sprain, A Strain or a Fracture?

By  aenriquez  published  November 12, 2019

People often debate this ancillary medical question: Which is worse, breaking an ankle or spraining an ankle? For all of that, what’s the difference between the two?

 

To answer those questions, let’s review all the possibilities. From a medical point of view, the question “which is the worst” of two non-lethal injuries is the same as what injury limits functioning the most, which one hurts the most or which is the most disfiguring.

 

Furthermore, there are three types of medical designations for routine injuries of this type: Sprains, breaks, and strains. Here’s the difference between these three:

 

 Strain

 

A strain is caused by sudden over-stretching, twisting or of a muscle or a tendon or both. A tendon is a fibrous band of tissue that connects a muscle to a bone.

 

Strains can be severe, causing intense pain, muscle spasms, inflammation, loss of strength and cramping. A strain can be either mild or severe with the worse cases involving tearing of either muscles or tendons, including tendons that detach from muscles or bones.

 

Strains commonly occur at the back of the hamstring muscle, which runs along the back of your thighs. A hamstring can be pulled by overstretching the leg, which might occur in running and then either accelerating quickly or jumping suddenly. Hamstrings are common to any sport where running is required.

 

Healing from a strained muscle or tendon

 

Healing from a strain can take up to six months or more. One of the problems with these types of injuries is that fully healing takes so long that re-injury is common.

 

The long and the short comes down to the time it takes to heal and the risk of re-injury

 

Sprains

 

A sprain, technically, is an overstretching of ligaments, which connect two bones, often wrapping around two bones of a joint to hold the joint into place. As such, injuries to knees, ankles and other joints frequently are sprains, rather than strains.

 

A sprain can be very painful, causing the area to swell up and turn various shades of blue, black and yellow or red. The intensity of a sprain depends on the severity of the injury, which could involve rupturing a ligament or having it separate from the bone it is expected to support. Severe sprains might include dislocation of the joint.

 

Fractures or breaks

 

A broken bone can be very painful, but it is not always so. While a clear break is certainly painful, fractures can be very slight (often called a hairline fracture) and relatively small. There is usually some pain involved with a slight fracture, but the area could also experience numbness without much pain.

 

Severity

 

The severity of an injury is dependent on related factors. How much does it hurt? How much does treatment cost? How long does it take to heal? Is the injury likely to reoccur?

 

By several of these measurements sprains and strains could be said to be worse than breaks or fractures, if there is no surgery involved. Treatment of the fracture might be more expensive initially if a cast is required for stabilization, but severe sprains are also treated with stabilizing casts.

 

Here’s the breakdown. As far as pain, it is hard to conclude either of these is more painful than the other. A broken bone can be extremely painful at first, but a hamstring pull is often just as painful. A badly sprained ankle can also be painful. We have to consider this a virtual three-way tie.

 

The long and the short comes down to the time it takes to heal and the risk of re-injury. In this case, a sprain can take even longer to heal than a fracture or a broken bone and is far more likely to reoccur. A healed bone is almost as strong as one that never broke in the first place, whereas the soft tissue damage from a sprain or strain can persist for a long time, increasing the chances of re-injury.

 

How can you tell the difference?

 

Modern medical imaging (an X-ray or a CT Scan) is used to diagnose a sprain, strain or fracture, but you can make an educated guess when the injury occurs. Sprains and strains hurt primarily in an area of soft tissue, while bone pain (and swelling) occurs where the bone is the primary structure. Secondly, a broken bone or a fracture often results in numbness, where a sprain and/or strain do not.

 

 Help!

 

Any sprain, strain, fracture or break should be seen by a doctor as soon as possible to prevent further injury. Let us help you return to an active lifestyle with minimum pain. Call FXRX Orthopaedics and Bracing in Phoenix, Az., at 480-449-FXRX.

Continue Reading

Leave a Reply