Now accepting Telehealth appointments. Schedule a virtual visit.
Skip to main content

When Is Shoulder Arthroscopy A Better Option Than Open Surgery?

Subacromial decompression is a surgery that treats shoulder impingement syndrome and can be done through an open incision or arthroscopically.

Surgeries such as open decompression or arthroscopy have almost the same results in a reduction in pain ranging in almost 77-90 percent of the patients. The methods to be used are dictated largely by the surgeon’s preferences and the condition of the patient.

When Is Shoulder Arthroscopy A Better Option Than Open Surgery?

Arthroscopic surgery

A minimal two to three small cuts are made surrounding the shoulder during the surgery. An arthroscope, which is a small viewing device is inserted in the cut. The surgeon can look inside through the camera and check the biceps and joints along with the rotator cuff tendons to any issues that can otherwise be overlooked or go unnoticed in an MRI or an open procedure.

Arthroscopic surgery is generally recommended for people who are young and have a mild impingement in the shoulder. It is done to promote regaining of daily activities. Moderate shoulder impingement refers to pain which hinders daily life activities. It often occurs in individuals around the age of 25 to 40 years old.

When is it not recommended?

It is generally not recommended for people who experience the following:

Open Surgery

This procedure involves a large incision of about 4-6 cm. It is necessary for patients who have a large rotator cuff tear. In many cases, surgeons recommend open surgeries compared to other options as it allows them access to a large area of injury. On the other hand, however, a large incision increases the chance of infection. Patients who undergo open surgery may have to spend 1-2 nights in the hospital for recovery.

Open Surgery vs Arthroscopic

Open surgeries are for external rotation while arthroscopic procedures are linked with less motion. Open surgery can be performed faster, while arthroscopic procedures require a detail-oriented set of skills.

Many surgeons are comfortable with open surgeries for the latter can be a difficult procedure. Recovery time varies for both, and in general, takes 3-6 months to fully recover. People may be able to use the affected arm by two weeks of the surgery.

It is reported that people who go through arthroscopic surgery recover faster, and experience less pain during the recovery period. The recovery process involves stretching and exercise that prevents swelling and stiffness. In both cases, a therapist would likely be involved to assist the patient with exercises that promote healing and recovery.

Risks

There are potential risks of both types of surgeries, including:

You Might Also Enjoy...

Chronic Foot Pain: Could It Be a Stress Fracture?

Foot pain can stem from various causes, ranging from minor injuries to more serious conditions. One often overlooked but relatively frequent cause of chronic foot pain is a stress fracture. Our specialty team explains.
Benefits of Custom Orthopedic Bracing

Benefits of Custom Orthopedic Bracing

Various injuries and chronic conditions benefit from orthopedic bracing, from preserving joints through recovery to enhancing comfort as you go about your daily routine. Our specialty team discusses why custom bracing often offers the best solutions.

Degenerative Rotator Cuff Tears: What You Need to Know

Degenerative rotator cuff tears can cause significant pain and limit shoulder function, but you don’t have to live with the discomfort. There may be steps you can take to reduce the risk of this often age-related problem.

I Was Injured at Work: What Are My Next Steps?

Depending on its severity, any injury can cause significant pain and disability as you undergo diagnosis, treatment, and recovery. Work injuries can add extra layers of stress due to the steps you must take during the process. We can help.
4 Benefits of Knee Arthroscopy

4 Benefits of Knee Arthroscopy

Arthroscopy offers a minimally invasive solution for knee pain that can get you back on your feet faster than you might think. Learn more from our specialty team about what to expect after knee arthroscopy and who benefits
Why Is PRP Popular Among Athletes?

Why Is PRP Popular Among Athletes?

The demand for effective, natural treatments that can heal injuries and boost performance continues to evolve for athletes at all levels. PRP therapy promises to do just that. Dive into how PRP works and its pro-athlete benefits.